8.75°C Vancouver

Apr 6, 2023 6:28 PM - The Canadian Press

Supreme Court of Canada won't hear appeal involving private health care

Share On
supreme-court-of-canada-wont-hear-appeal-involving-private-health-care
Two Vancouver private health facilities and four patients argued that provisions of the Medicare Protection Act violate constitutional rights due to long waits for care in B.C.'s publicly funded system.

The Supreme Court of Canada will not hear a challenge of a British Columbia law intended to preserve public health care through measures against extra-billing and certain private insurance.

Two Vancouver private health facilities and four patients argued that provisions of the Medicare Protection Act violate constitutional rights due to long waits for care in B.C.'s publicly funded system.

They said this amounted to a breach of the patients' life, liberty and security of the person under the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.

Three years ago, the Supreme Court of British Columbia dismissed the constitutional challenge.

Justice John Steeves said while long waits for care might increase the risk to some patients, the provisions were justified by the overall objective of supporting a system in which access to health care is based on need, not the ability to pay.

The B.C. Court of Appeal upheld the decision last year, prompting the parties to take their case to the Supreme Court of Canada.

Latest news

canada-and-taiwan-could-sign-trade-deal-soon-carney-signals
CanadaNov 18, 2026

Canada and Taiwan Could Sign Trade Deal Soon, Carney Signals

Canada and Taiwan could soon sign a trade agreement, Prime Minister Mark Carney has indicated. In a statement, Carney said he expects the deal, which was finalized more than a year ago, to be signed in the near future. The Trade and Economic Cooperation Framework Agreement with Taiwan was completed in March 2025. Speaking at a news conference in Shenzhen on Wednesday, Carney was asked why the agreement had remained on hold for nearly a year. He said he hopes it will be signed soon. The House of Commons Foreign Affairs Committee has also recommended that the government finalize the agreement, d
mission-b-c-sees-two-serious-crashes-overnight-cyclist-killed-pedestrian-critically-injured
BCNov 18, 2026

Mission, B.C., Sees Two Serious Crashes Overnight; Cyclist Killed, Pedestrian Critically Injured

In Mission, B.C., two serious road incidents occurred overnight, leaving one cyclist dead and another man critically injured after being run over by a pickup truck. According to Mission RCMP spokesperson Harrison Mohr, the first incident occurred around 12:20 a.m. near 3rd Avenue on Stave Lake Street, where a 36-year-old man was lying on the roadside when a pickup truck drove over him. The seriously injured victim was airlifted to hospital. Police have seized the suspected truck involved in the incident. About two hours later, around 2 a.m., another serious collision occurred on Lougheed Highw
CanadaNov 18, 2026

Ontario Police Bust Major GTA Tow Truck Organized Crime Ring; 21 Arrested, Including Correctional Officer

Police in Ontario have dismantled a major organized crime network operating in the tow truck industry across the Greater Toronto Area (GTA). A total of 21 people, including a correctional officer, have been arrested in the operation and are facing a combined 112 charges. Among those named in the case are 26-year-old Kiranpal Toor of Caledon, 31-year-old Shiv Patel of Toronto and 38-year-old Dinesh Battula of Toronto. According to Toronto Police, the investigation, dubbed Project Swords, was launched in September 2025 in partnership with York Regional Police, Durham Regional Police Service and
several-teens-arrested-after-group-assault-on-boy-at-mission-skate-park
BCNov 18, 2026

Several Teens Arrested After Group Assault on Boy at Mission Skate Park

Several teenagers have been arrested by RCMP in connection with a group assault on a young boy at a park in Mission, B.C. Mission RCMP first received a complaint about the incident on October 30 from a parent, who reported that a boy had been attacked at the skate park outside the Mission Leisure Centre on Grand Street. The assault was also captured on video. Providing an update on the investigation Wednesday, police said all the youths involved in the incident have been identified. They are residents of Mission and are between 13 and 15 years old. However, police have not confirmed how many m
AlbertaNov 18, 2026

Alberta Auditor General Unable to Set Timeline for Health-Care Contract Scandal Probe

Alberta’s Auditor General says he cannot provide a definite timeline for completing the ongoing investigation into the province’s health-care contracting scandal. Phil Peters had earlier indicated that the review of health-care procurement processes was expected to be completed by the end of this year. The investigation was launched following allegations of corruption involving multi-million-dollar health-care contracts made by former Alberta Health Services CEO Athana Mentzelopoulos. However, the allegations have not been proven, and Premier Danielle Smith’s government has denied any wr

Related News