5.93°C Vancouver

Jan 11, 2020 12:35 AM -

B.C. Appeal Court tosses dad's latest attempt to stop child's gender change

Share On

British Columbia's Appeal Court has reaffirmed a teenager's decision to have gender transition treatment and urged the boy's father to try to understand his son's gender dysphoria.

The father, whose identity is under a publication ban along with his son's, went to court when he learned his female-born child was undergoing hormone therapy because he perceived himself to be a male.

The B.C. Supreme Court sided with the boy in an earlier decision, saying he didn't need his father's consent for treatment, and an injunction was later issued against the dad ordering that any attempt to persuade the boy to abandon treatment was a form of family violence. In a decision released Friday, the Appeal Court said the father is entitled to his beliefs but his son is a mature 15 year old and has chosen hormone treatment.

It overturned parts of the lower court ruling that limited what the father could say about the child's transition, but it still said he must acknowledge and refer to his child as a male and by the name the teen has chosen. In the decision, Chief Justice Robert Bauman and Justice Barbara Fisher wrote that the father's refusal to respect his son's decision has caused the boy "significant pain," resulting in a breach in what was an otherwise loving parent-child relationship.

"This rupture is not in (the boy's) best interests. He clearly wants and needs acceptance and support from his father."

The judges say the father's attempts to be involved in the process have been by fuelled by positional stances without any direct involvement with the boy's medical team, which has tried to speak to him.

They urged the father to engage with the boy's medical team and to listen to the teenager.

"If he fails to do these two things, the rupture in his relationship with (his son) will likely not heal, which would not be in (the boy's) best interests."


Latest news

BCNov 19, 2026

B.C. Premier-Designate Lorne Doerkson and 64 Conservative MLAs to Be Sworn In Today

The swearing-in ceremony will take place in two groups. The first group, including Doerkson, will take the oath at 3:30 p.m., while the second group will be sworn in at 6 p.m. On Friday, Doerkson will be officially sworn in as B.C.’s 38th premier at Government House, where he is also expected to announce his cabinet. About two months ago, former premier David Eby called a snap election, saying he wanted a stronger mandate to deal with U.S. President Donald Trump’s tariffs. However, issues such as hospital services and the province’s $14-billion deficit dominated the election campaign. Th
prosecutors-seek-two-year-sentence-for-ex-rbc-employee-in-carney-banking-data-theft-case
CanadaNov 19, 2026

Prosecutors Seek Two-Year Sentence for Ex-RBC Employee in Carney Banking Data Theft Case

Prosecutors are seeking a two-year prison sentence for a former Royal Bank of Canada (RBC) employee who pleaded guilty to illegally accessing Prime Minister Mark Carney’s personal banking information and opening dozens of fraudulent bank accounts. Ibrahim Al-Hakim, 24, who worked at an RBC branch in Ottawa, pleaded guilty in August to fraud over $5,000, unauthorized use of a computer and identity theft. A sentencing hearing was held in an Ontario court on Wednesday, but Al-Hakim failed to appear for the second consecutive time. The Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) suspects he has been ou
BCNov 19, 2026

Victims of Surrey Walmart Double Homicide Identified

The victims of a double homicide in a Walmart parking lot in Surrey on the night of November 15 have been identified. The Integrated Homicide Investigation Team (IHIT) identified the victims as 23-year-old Gaganpreet Rehal, also known as Gary, and 24-year-old Sukhjeet Kaur, both residents of Delta. IHIT is investigating the shooting as a targeted killing, with indications of links to organized crime. Police said the two victims were shot at around 10:38 p.m. Sunday in the Walmart parking lot near 88 Avenue and 124 Street. Both later died in hospital. A burned vehicle found in the 9700-block of
87-year-old-woman-dies-after-vancouver-hit-and-run-collision
BCNov 19, 2026

87-Year-Old Woman Dies After Vancouver Hit-and-Run Collision

An 87-year-old woman who was seriously injured in a hit-and-run collision in Vancouver has died in hospital. The incident happened at around 7:30 a.m. on November 11, Remembrance Day, near Dunbar Street and West 41st Avenue. Police say the woman was crossing the road in a marked crosswalk when she was struck by a light-coloured Mercedes-Benz C-Class. The driver failed to stop at the scene and fled after the collision. According to police, the woman, who was taken to hospital with serious injuries, died yesterday. Investigators have released an image of the suspect vehicle and are asking anyone
BCNov 19, 2026

B.C. MLAs' Swearing-In Schedule Announced, Next Legislative Session Set for New Year

The swearing-in schedule for British Columbia’s newly elected MLAs has been announced. MLAs from the majority-winning B.C. Conservative Party will be sworn into office tomorrow at the Legislative Assembly in Victoria. On Friday, Lorne Doerkson will be officially sworn in as premier, along with his new cabinet, during a separate ceremony at Government House. Meanwhile, Green Party Leader Emily Lowan and the party’s other MLA will take their oaths on November 23, while the 27 MLAs of the main opposition B.C. NDP will be sworn in on November 26. The incoming B.C. Conservative government has a

Related News