6.71°C Vancouver

Jan 11, 2020 12:35 AM -

B.C. Appeal Court tosses dad's latest attempt to stop child's gender change

Share On

British Columbia's Appeal Court has reaffirmed a teenager's decision to have gender transition treatment and urged the boy's father to try to understand his son's gender dysphoria.

The father, whose identity is under a publication ban along with his son's, went to court when he learned his female-born child was undergoing hormone therapy because he perceived himself to be a male.

The B.C. Supreme Court sided with the boy in an earlier decision, saying he didn't need his father's consent for treatment, and an injunction was later issued against the dad ordering that any attempt to persuade the boy to abandon treatment was a form of family violence. In a decision released Friday, the Appeal Court said the father is entitled to his beliefs but his son is a mature 15 year old and has chosen hormone treatment.

It overturned parts of the lower court ruling that limited what the father could say about the child's transition, but it still said he must acknowledge and refer to his child as a male and by the name the teen has chosen. In the decision, Chief Justice Robert Bauman and Justice Barbara Fisher wrote that the father's refusal to respect his son's decision has caused the boy "significant pain," resulting in a breach in what was an otherwise loving parent-child relationship.

"This rupture is not in (the boy's) best interests. He clearly wants and needs acceptance and support from his father."

The judges say the father's attempts to be involved in the process have been by fuelled by positional stances without any direct involvement with the boy's medical team, which has tried to speak to him.

They urged the father to engage with the boy's medical team and to listen to the teenager.

"If he fails to do these two things, the rupture in his relationship with (his son) will likely not heal, which would not be in (the boy's) best interests."


Latest news

two-south-asian-victims-identified-in-fatal-shooting-at-surrey-walmart-parking-lot
BCNov 16, 2026

Two South Asian Victims Identified in Fatal Shooting at Surrey Walmart Parking Lot

Two people, a 23-year-old man and a 24-year-old woman, have been identified as the victims of a fatal shooting at a Walmart parking lot near 88 Avenue and 124 Street in Surrey Sunday night. Both victims were of South Asian descent and residents of Delta. Speaking at a news conference Monday morning, Sgt. Freda Fong of the Integrated Homicide Investigation Team (IHIT) said the male victim was already known to police due to previous offences involving weapons and firearms. Police have not yet released the names of either victim. Investigators found a red Ford Mustang riddled with bullet holes at
aap-to-hold-mega-rally-in-moga-on-november-26-ahead-of-2027-punjab-assembly-elections
IndiaNov 16, 2026

AAP to Hold Mega Rally in Moga on November 26 Ahead of 2027 Punjab Assembly Elections

The Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) will hold a massive rally in Moga on November 26 as it prepares for the 2027 Punjab Assembly elections. The rally will be organised on the occasion of the party’s 14th Foundation Day and Constitution Day. AAP National Convenor Arvind Kejriwal, Punjab Chief Minister Bhagwant Mann and other senior party leaders are expected to attend the event. The rally is being viewed as the beginning of AAP’s election campaign in Punjab ahead of the 2027 Assembly polls. Through the event, the party is expected to showcase its political strength in the state and present its agenda
63-year-old-woman-seriously-injured-in-abbotsford-hit-and-run
BCNov 16, 2026

63-Year-Old Woman Seriously Injured in Abbotsford Hit-and-Run

Police in Abbotsford are investigating a hit-and-run collision that left a 63-year-old woman seriously injured. According to police, the incident occurred around 6:30 p.m. Friday at the intersection of Garibaldi Drive and Gladwin Road. Initial investigations indicate that the woman was crossing the street on foot when she was struck by a black SUV. The driver failed to stop or provide assistance and fled the scene in the vehicle. Police said the woman suffered serious injuries but was not considered to be in life-threatening condition. She was taken to hospital for treatment. Investigators are
surrey-police-seek-witnesses-and-video-footage-in-fatal-tree-fall-incident
BCNov 16, 2026

Surrey Police Seek Witnesses and Video Footage in Fatal Tree-Fall Incident

Surrey Police are appealing to witnesses and anyone with dashcam or video footage to come forward in connection with a fatal incident earlier this month in which a driver was killed after a tree fell on their vehicle during a severe windstorm. According to police, the incident occurred at approximately 8 p.m. on November 7 in the 18000-block of Highway 10, where a tree fell onto a white Toyota Prius, trapping the driver inside. Emergency crews arrived at the scene and made every effort to rescue the driver, but the individual was pronounced dead at the scene. Surrey Police said several people
ucp-divided-over-separation-issue-danielle-smith-to-personally-speak-with-officials
AlbertaNov 16, 2026

UCP Divided Over Separation Issue, Danielle Smith to Personally Speak with Officials

Alberta Premier Danielle Smith says she plans to personally contact United Conservative Party (UCP) officials who have refused to sign a pledge opposing separation. The presidents of 15 UCP constituency associations have rejected the party’s new code of conduct requirement, arguing that it violates their freedom of thought and expression. The pledge requires party officials to respect the outcome of last month’s referendum, in which Alberta voters rejected holding a binding vote on separation. Smith says the dispute is about maintaining party unity ahead of next year’s provincial electio

Related News