17.16°C Vancouver

Aug 16, 2024 3:49 PM - The Canadian Press

CBSA to use facial recognition app for people facing deportation: documents

Share On
cbsa-to-use-facial-recognition-app-for-people-facing-deportation-documents
Experts are flagging numerous concerns, questioning the validity of user consent and potential secrecy around how the technology makes its decisions.(Photo: The Canadian Press)

The Canada Border Services Agency plans to implement an app that uses facial recognition technology to keep track of people who have been ordered to be deported from the country.

The mobile reporting app would use biometrics to confirm a person's identity and record their location data when they use the app to check in. Documents obtained through access-to-information indicate that the CBSA has proposed such an app as far back as 2021.

A spokesperson confirmed that an app called ReportIn will be launched this fall.

Experts are flagging numerous concerns, questioning the validity of user consent and potential secrecy around how the technology makes its decisions.

Each year, about 2,000 people who have been ordered to leave the country fail to show up, meaning the CBSA "must spend considerable resources investigating, locating and in some cases detaining these clients," says a 2021 document.

The agency pitched a smartphone app as an "ideal solution."

Getting regular updates through the app on a person's "residential address, employment, family status, among other things, will allow the CBSA to have relevant information that can be used to contact and monitor the client for any early indicators of non-compliance," it said.

"Additionally, given the automation, it is more likely that the client will feel engaged and will recognize the level of visibility the CBSA has on their case."

Plus, the document noted: "If a client fails to appear for removal, the information gathered through the app will provide good investigative leads for locating the client."

An algorithmic impact assessment for the project — not yet posted on the federal government's website — said biometric voice technology the CBSA tried using was being phased out due to "failing technology," and it developed the ReportIn app to replace it.

It said a person's "facial biometrics and location, provided by sensors and/or the GPS in the mobile device/smartphone" are recorded through the ReportIn app and then sent to the CBSA's back-end system.

Once people submit photos, a "facial comparison algorithm" will generate a similarity score to a reference photo.

If the system doesn't confirm a facial match, it triggers a process for officers to investigate the case.

"The individuals’ location is also collected every time they report and if the individual fails to comply with their conditions," it said. The document noted individuals will not be "constantly tracked."

The app uses technology from Amazon Web Services. That's a choice that grabbed the attention of Brenda McPhail, the director of executive education in McMaster University's public policy in digital society program.

She said while many facial recognition companies submit their algorithms for testing to the U.S. National Institute of Standards and Technology, Amazon has never voluntarily done so.

An Amazon Web Services spokesperson said its Amazon Rekognition technology is "tested extensively including by third parties like Credo AI, a company that specializes in Responsible AI, and iBeta Quality Assurance."

The spokesperson added that Amazon Rekognition is a "large-scale cloud-based system and therefore not downloadable as described in the NIST participation guidance."

"That is why our Rekognition Face Liveness was instead submitted for testing against industry standards to iBeta Lab," which is accredited by the institute as an independent test lab, the spokesperson said.

The CBSA document says the algorithm used will be a trade secret. In a situation that could have life-changing consequences, McPhail asked whether it's "appropriate to use a tool that is protected by trade secrets or proprietary secrets and that denies people the right to understand how decisions about them are truly being made."

Kristen Thomasen, an associate professor and chair in law, robotics and society at the University of Windsor, said the reference to trade secrets is a signal there could be legal impediments blocking information about the system.

There's been concern for years about people who are subject to errors in systems being legally prohibited from getting more information because of intellectual property protections, she explained.

CBSA spokesperson Maria Ladouceur said the agency "developed this smartphone app to allow foreign nationals and permanent residents subject to immigration enforcement conditions to report without coming in-person to a CBSA office."

She said the agency "worked in close consultation" with the Office of the Privacy Commissioner on the app. "Enrolment in ReportIn will be voluntary, and users will need to consent to both using the app, and the use of their likeness to verify their identity."

Petra Molnar, the associate director of York University's refugee law lab, said there is a power imbalance between the agency implementing the app and the people on the receiving end.

"Can a person really, truly consent in this situation where there is a vast power differential?"

If an individual doesn't consent to participate, they can report in-person as an alternative, Ladouceur said.

Thomasen also cautioned there is a risk of errors with facial recognition technology, and that risk is higher for racialized individuals and people with darker skin.

Molnar said it's "very troubling that there is basically no discussion of … human rights impacts in the documents."

The CBSA spokesperson said Credo AI reviewed the software for bias against demographic groups, and found a 99.9 per cent facial match rate across six different demographic groups, adding the app "will be continuously tested after launch to assess accuracy and performance."

The final decision will be made by a human, with officers overseeing all submissions, but the experts noted humans tend to trust judgements made by technology.

Thomasen said there is a "fairly widely recognized … psychological tendency for people to defer to the expertise of the computer system," where computer systems are perceived to be less biased or more accurate.

Latest news

major-police-operation-near-kilmore-crescent-area-in-surrey-sps-confirms-multiple-arrests
BCOct 05, 2025

Major police operation near Kilmore Crescent area in Surrey, SPS confirms multiple arrests

A major police operation was carried out in the area of ​​Kilmore Crescent, near 152nd Street and 60th Avenue, in Surrey today. During this time, a large number of police officers approached a house in the area and multiple people were arrested. The police are yet to release any official information in the case, but some residents of the neighborhood told the Connect FM team that at least 3 people were arrested. Connect FM spoke to Sergeant Tige Pollock, Media Relations Officer for Surrey Police Service, for more information on the matter. He said “a police team is still at the property
anand-set-to-host-fellow-g7-foreign-ministers-in-november-near-niagara-falls
CanadaOct 03, 2025

G7 Foreign Ministers to Meet in Niagara Region Next Month for Security and Economic Talks

Canada will host foreign ministers from the Group of Seven nations next month for two days of high-level discussions on global security and economic resilience. The meetings, scheduled for November 11 and 12, will take place in Ontario’s Niagara Region. Foreign Affairs Minister Anita Anand will chair the session, welcoming her counterparts from France, Germany, Italy, Japan, the United Kingdom, the United States, and representatives of the European Union. The gathering follows a ministerial meeting held in Quebec earlier this year and the G7 leaders’ summit in Alberta in June. Global Affai
police-first-responders-scramble-to-help-woman-give-birth-on-victoria-waterfront
BCOct 03, 2025

Police, first responders scramble to help woman give birth on Victoria waterfront

Emergency responders in Victoria, B.C., had to rush into action to support a woman giving birth on Wharf Street, along the city's busy waterfront area. Victoria police say an officer and St. John Ambulance members were working at a local event on Sept. 20 when a passerby notified them of a woman in labour. Police say the officer and other responders found the woman who was in active labour and helped support her along with other members of the public. The newborn was delivered before paramedics could arrive. Police say the baby appeared healthy while being cared for by emergency responders, al
b-c-public-workers-expand-pickets-again-to-more-liquor-cannabis-retail-stores
BCOct 03, 2025

B.C. public workers expand pickets again to more liquor, cannabis retail stores

Striking public service workers in British Columbia have expanded pickets at provincial liquor and cannabis stores again, adding 20 more locations to the list. The B.C. General Employees’ Union says the escalation also includes job action by front-line staff at several ministry offices. It says more than 17,000 public service workers are now taking job action across the province, which is half the 34,000 workers represented by the union. Union president Paul Finch says in a statement that every day the government delays, pressure on public services will grow, and it will continue to step up
kapil-sharmas-kaps-cafe-reopens-in-canada
BCOct 03, 2025

Kap's Cafe reopens again after second shooting incident

Kap's Cafe, which was the target of two shootings in Surrey, has reopened again. The cafe was closed for about 10 days after the first shooting on July 10. Kapil Sharma had initially shared a post about the cafe's reopening, but within weeks of reopening in July, the cafe was again the target of a shooting in early August. The cafe reopened again on October 1, the Connect FM team reached the cafe on Thursday (Oct. 2nd) and tried to get comments from the cafe manager. The manager denied any comment on camera and said that the management had refused to provide any official information. At aroun

Related News